You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
I wrote a simple app to get the actual hit percentage chances using the logic from ArtilleryStrikeArrivalAction_Settlement using a 250x250 map and a base of size 36. Send 50 mln high explosive shells, 48.7 mln missed (48719526, 97.44%), 1.02 mln hit without destroying the base (1021090, 2.04%), 259384 destroyed base (0.52% of all shells, 25.4% of hits).
It means the expected number of shells to send to hit a base is 49 shells and to destroy it is 192 high explosive shells. It would cost 4800 steel and 2880 chemfuel. Firing one shell takes 8.5 sec of real-time cooldown + 8 sec real-time warmup = 16.5 sec real-time which is about 24 in-game minutes (https://rimworldwiki.com/wiki/Time ), which means to fire 192 he shells it would take 3 days and 4 hours of constant firing or 9.5 days of firing 8-hours/day. Or in other terms: more than it takes for rice or potatoe to grow or to travel over 170 tiles though a forest without using any roads.
In other terms: in my opinion the 2% chance of hitting a base with artilley is way to small, it should be somewhere between 15%-20% with the same destroy chance, then it would take 5-7 shells to hit and 20-28 shells to destroy a base and would make the artillery actually useful
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Hello,
I wrote a simple app to get the actual hit percentage chances using the logic from ArtilleryStrikeArrivalAction_Settlement using a 250x250 map and a base of size 36. Send 50 mln high explosive shells, 48.7 mln missed (48719526, 97.44%), 1.02 mln hit without destroying the base (1021090, 2.04%), 259384 destroyed base (0.52% of all shells, 25.4% of hits).
It means the expected number of shells to send to hit a base is 49 shells and to destroy it is 192 high explosive shells. It would cost 4800 steel and 2880 chemfuel. Firing one shell takes 8.5 sec of real-time cooldown + 8 sec real-time warmup = 16.5 sec real-time which is about 24 in-game minutes (https://rimworldwiki.com/wiki/Time ), which means to fire 192 he shells it would take 3 days and 4 hours of constant firing or 9.5 days of firing 8-hours/day. Or in other terms: more than it takes for rice or potatoe to grow or to travel over 170 tiles though a forest without using any roads.
In other terms: in my opinion the 2% chance of hitting a base with artilley is way to small, it should be somewhere between 15%-20% with the same destroy chance, then it would take 5-7 shells to hit and 20-28 shells to destroy a base and would make the artillery actually useful
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: