diff --git a/pcsx2/ImGui/FullscreenUI.cpp b/pcsx2/ImGui/FullscreenUI.cpp
index 3a8502f8b9969..c98fd5ab08a7a 100644
--- a/pcsx2/ImGui/FullscreenUI.cpp
+++ b/pcsx2/ImGui/FullscreenUI.cpp
@@ -4574,10 +4574,8 @@ void FullscreenUI::DrawPauseMenu(MainWindowType type)
 
 	// title info
 	{
-		const bool has_rich_presence = Achievements::IsActive() && !Achievements::GetRichPresenceString().empty();
-
-		const float image_width = has_rich_presence ? 60.0f : 50.0f;
-		const float image_height = has_rich_presence ? 90.0f : 75.0f;
+		const float image_width = 60.0f;
+		const float image_height = 90.0f;
 		const std::string_view path_string(Path::GetFileName(s_current_disc_path));
 		const ImVec2 title_size(
 			g_large_font->CalcTextSizeA(g_large_font->FontSize, std::numeric_limits<float>::max(), -1.0f, s_current_game_title.c_str()));
@@ -4596,43 +4594,42 @@ void FullscreenUI::DrawPauseMenu(MainWindowType type)
 			(path_string.empty() ? title_pos.y : path_pos.y) + g_medium_font->FontSize + LayoutScale(4.0f));
 
 		float rp_height = 0.0f;
-
-		DrawShadowedText(dl, g_large_font, title_pos, text_color, s_current_game_title.c_str());
-		if (!path_string.empty())
-		{
-			DrawShadowedText(dl, g_medium_font, path_pos, text_color, path_string.data(), path_string.data() + path_string.length());
-		}
-		DrawShadowedText(dl, g_medium_font, subtitle_pos, text_color, s_current_game_subtitle.c_str());
-
-		if (has_rich_presence)
 		{
 			const auto lock = Achievements::GetLock();
-			const std::string& rp = Achievements::GetRichPresenceString();
+			const std::string& rp = Achievements::IsActive() ? Achievements::GetRichPresenceString() : std::string();
+
 			if (!rp.empty())
 			{
 				const float wrap_width = LayoutScale(350.0f);
 				const ImVec2 rp_size = g_medium_font->CalcTextSizeA(
-					g_medium_font->FontSize, std::numeric_limits<float>::max(), wrap_width, rp.data(), rp.data() + rp.size());
+					g_medium_font->FontSize, std::numeric_limits<float>::max(), wrap_width, rp.data(), rp.data() + rp.length());
 
-				// we make the image one line higher, so we only need to compensate when it's multiline RP
-				rp_height = rp_size.y - g_medium_font->FontSize;
+				// Add a small extra gap if any Rich Presence is displayed
+				rp_height = rp_size.y - g_medium_font->FontSize + 2.0f;
 
-				const ImVec2 rp_pos(display_size.x - LayoutScale(20.0f + 50.0f + 20.0f) - rp_size.x - rp_height,
-					subtitle_pos.y + g_medium_font->FontSize + LayoutScale(4.0f));
+				const ImVec2 rp_pos(display_size.x - LayoutScale(20.0f + 50.0f + 20.0f) - rp_size.x,
+					subtitle_pos.y + g_medium_font->FontSize + LayoutScale(4.0f) - rp_height);
 
 				title_pos.y -= rp_height;
 				path_pos.y -= rp_height;
 				subtitle_pos.y -= rp_height;
 
-				DrawShadowedText(dl, g_medium_font, rp_pos, text_color, rp.data(), rp.data() + rp.size(), wrap_width);
+				DrawShadowedText(dl, g_medium_font, rp_pos, text_color, rp.data(), rp.data() + rp.length(), wrap_width);
 			}
 		}
 
+		DrawShadowedText(dl, g_large_font, title_pos, text_color, s_current_game_title.c_str());
+		if (!path_string.empty())
+		{
+			DrawShadowedText(dl, g_medium_font, path_pos, text_color, path_string.data(), path_string.data() + path_string.length());
+		}
+		DrawShadowedText(dl, g_medium_font, subtitle_pos, text_color, s_current_game_subtitle.c_str());
+
 
 		GSTexture* const cover = GetCoverForCurrentGame();
 		const ImVec2 image_min(
-			display_size.x - LayoutScale(10.0f + image_width) - rp_height, display_size.y - LayoutScale(10.0f + image_height) - rp_height);
-		const ImVec2 image_max(image_min.x + LayoutScale(image_width) + rp_height, image_min.y + LayoutScale(image_height) + rp_height);
+			display_size.x - LayoutScale(10.0f + image_width), display_size.y - LayoutScale(10.0f + image_height) - rp_height);
+		const ImVec2 image_max(image_min.x + LayoutScale(image_width), image_min.y + LayoutScale(image_height) + rp_height);
 		const ImRect image_rect(CenterImage(
 			ImRect(image_min, image_max), ImVec2(static_cast<float>(cover->GetWidth()), static_cast<float>(cover->GetHeight()))));
 		dl->AddImage(cover->GetNativeHandle(), image_rect.Min, image_rect.Max);