added machine translated hint to information_page.html #629
Conversation
wouldn't it be more important for minutes? IMO translations of information pages are more carefully checked than minutes translations |
|
I would wish this being configurable on a per-page basis, as there are some pages that are actively curated in English |
| {% get_language_info for LANGUAGE_CODE as lang %} | ||
| {% if lang.code == "en" %} | ||
| <aside class="side-panel border-accent"> | ||
| This has page has been machine-translated. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
| This has page has been machine-translated. | |
| This page may have been machine-translated. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I think this would be better since other Gremien may actually manually translate it.
Also we could think about explaining it better. Why is it machine translated? What can I do about it?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
tbh, I don't think that a "may be machine translated" notice on all English pages provides any useful information. Can I trust this information? – Maybe.
Is there a reason why you prefer the "maybe" wording over my suggestion of making this configurable per page and provide reliable information ("is/is not machine translated")?
other Gremien may actually manually translate it
The FSR also translates some information pages by hand or at least reviews the automatic translation before publishing the page.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I agree that for a user, an explicit "is" would be more valuable.With the current specification of the issue I believe "may" is the best solution. This means I will be alerted to possible weirdness and know I will ask if something is unclear.
But if we expand the scope we can also have the is / is not . But I think this definitely needs to be set at the time of translation, automatically. So it may be more complicated, and I think this version would already be helpful (though the note may need to be expanded to explain a little better why the hint is therek
There was a problem hiding this comment.
But I think this definitely needs to be set at the time of translation
Yes, this should be set when translating a page
automatically
Only if it it still possible to change this. Otherwise, it would not be possible to machine-translate a page, review it (without any need for changes) and then publish it without a warning.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Only if it it still possible to change this. Otherwise, it would not be possible to machine-translate a page, review it (without any need for changes) and then publish it without a warning.
Agreed. The question remains whether this PR (in some form, e.g. adapted wording ) is useful or not.
added machine translated hint to information_page.html